Seminole County Clerk of Courthttp://www.seminoleclerk.org/CriminalDo ... 2CF001083ARecent Entries:MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE07/17/2013 RFRE RECEIPT FOR RELEASE OF EVIDENCE
07/16/2013 RFRE RECEIPT FOR RELEASE OF EVIDENCE
07/13/2013 JDNG JUDGMENT OF NOT GUILTY
07/13/2013 VRFN VERDICT FORM NOT GUILTY-REDACTED
07/13/2013 OCTM OPEN COURT TRIAL MINUTES
07/13/2013 LOPE SEALED ENVELOPE-VERDICT FORM
07/13/2013 LOPE SEALED ENVELOPE-4 JURY QUESTIONS
07/13/2013 JUIF JURY INSTRUCTION FORM
07/13/2013 EXID EXHIBIT & IDENTIFICATION LIST
07/13/2013 EXID EXHIBIT & IDENTIFICATION LIST-REDACTED
07/13/2013 MNF1 1ST AMENDED MINUTES FOR TRIAL BEFORE JUDGE DEBRA S NELSON
07/13/2013 MNFD DEFENDANT WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/13/2013 MNFD STATE ATTORNEY BERNIE DE LA RIONDA/JOHN GUY/RICHARD MANTEI WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/13/2013 MNFD DEFENSE ATTORNEY O'MARA, MARK M & DON WEST WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL.
07/13/2013 MNFD JURY RETURNED WITH A VERDICT OF NOT GUILTY
07/13/2013 MNFD BOND RELEASED
07/13/2013 MNFD COURT, COUNSEL, AND DEFENDANT WERE PRESENT AND THE JURY CONTINUED WITH THEIR
07/13/2013 MNFD DELIBERATIONS. THE JURY RETURNED WITH A QUESTION AND THE COURT AND COUNSEL
07/13/2013 MNFD REVIEWED THE QUESTION AND PROVIDED AN ANSWER TO THE JURY IN WRITING.
07/13/2013 MNFD THE JURY RETURNED WITH THEIR VERDICT IT WAS AS FOLLOWS, "WE THE JURY FIND THE
07/13/2013 MNFD DEFENDANT NOT GUILTY." THE GPS MONITOR TO BE REMOVED AT THIS TIME. ALL EVIDENCE
07/13/2013 MNFD IS RELEASED TO THE APPROPRIATE PARTY.
07/13/2013 MNFD CORRECTED DUE TO SCRIVENERS ERROR.
07/13/2013 MNF MINUTES FOR TRIAL BEFORE JUDGE DEBRA S NELSON
07/12/2013 MNF MINUTES FOR TRIAL BEFORE JUDGE DEBRA S NELSON
07/12/2013 MNFD STATE ATTORNEY B. DE LA RIONDA/J. GUY/R. MANTEI WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/12/2013 MNFD DEFENSE ATTORNEY M. O'MARA/D. WEST WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/12/2013 MNFD COURT RECONVENED AT 8:30AM ON FRIDAY; JULY 12, 2013 WITH THE DEFENDANT,
07/12/2013 MNFD --COUNSEL AND COURT PERSONNEL PRESENT READY TO PROCEED. ATTORNEY O'MARA
07/12/2013 MNFD --PRESENTED CLOSING ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE DEFENSE.ATTORNEY GUY PRESENTED
07/12/2013 MNFD --REBUTTAL CLOSING ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE.COURT CHARGED THE JURY.
07/12/2013 MNFD --COURT THANKED AND EXCUSED THE ALTERNATE JURORS. JURY RETIRED FOR DELIBERATIONS
07/12/2013 MNFD --WITH EVIDENCE, INSTRUCTIONS ON THE LAW AND THE VERDICT FORM. JURY
07/12/2013 MNFD --QUESTIONS WERE READ INTO THE RECORD AND ANSWERS WERE STIPULATED TO BY DEFENSE
07/12/2013 MNFD --AND STATE. COURT ORDERED JURY QUESTIONS TO REMAIN UNDER SEAL UNTIL FURTHER
07/12/2013 MNFD --ORDER OF THE COURT.COURT GAVE CAUTIONARY INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY AND
07/12/2013 MNFD --EXCUSED THEM FOR THE DAY TO RETURN ON SATURDAY, JULY 13, 2013 AT 9AM TO
07/12/2013 MNFD --CONTINUE DELIBERATIONS.
07/12/2013 MNFD (1)MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE 782.04(2) 775.087(1)(A) F-L: DEFENDANT
07/12/2013 MNFD --CONTINUED ON BOND
07/12/2013 PRES DEFENDANT WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/12/2013 ORFF ORDER TO SEAL ENVELOPE-POTENTIAL JUROR QUESTIONNAIRES
07/12/2013 ORFF ORDER TO SEAL ENVELOPE-LETTERS FROM POTENTIAL JURORS
07/12/2013 ORFF ORDER TO SEAL ENVELOPE
07/11/2013 MNF MINUTES FOR TRIAL BEFORE JUDGE DEBRA S NELSON
07/11/2013 MNFD STATE ATTORNEY BERNIE DE LA RIONDA/JOHN GUY/RICHARD MANTEI WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/11/2013 MNFD DEFENSE ATTORNEY O'MARA, MARK M & DON WEST WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/11/2013 MNFD COURT, COUNSEL, DEFENDANT, AND COURT PERSONNEL WERE PRESENT AND READY TO
07/11/2013 MNFD --PROCEED.CHARGE CONFERENCE WAS HELD.ATTY DE LA RIONDA FURTHER RESTED THE
07/11/2013 MNFD --STATE'S CASE.ATTY DE LA RIONDA PRESENTED CLOSING ARGUMENT ON BEHALF OF THE
07/11/2013 MNFD --STATE.THE JURY WAS EXCUSED, WITH CAUTIONARY INSTRUCTIONS, TO RETURN BY 830AM
07/11/2013 MNFD --ON FRIDAY JULY 12,2013, TO CONTINUE WITH CLOSINGS.
07/11/2013 MNFD (1)MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE 782.04(2) 775.087(1)(A) F-L: DEFENDANT
07/11/2013 MNFD --CONTINUED ON BOND
07/11/2013 PRES DEFENDANT WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/11/2013 TRJU TRIAL CONTINUED TO 07/12/2013 AT 0830AM IN COURTROOM 5D, AT CRIMINAL JUSTICE
07/11/2013 TRJU --BUILDING BEFORE JUDGE DEBRA S NELSON MANDATORY COURT APPEARANCE.
07/10/2013 FREE REQUEST TO TAKE JUDICIAL NOTICE
07/10/2013 FREE REQUEST TO TAKE JUDICIAL NOTICE
07/10/2013 MNF MINUTES FOR TRIAL BEFORE JUDGE DEBRA S NELSON
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENDANT SWORN
07/10/2013 MNFD STATE ATTORNEY B.DE LA RIONDA/J.GUY/R.MANTEI WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENSE ATTORNEY M.O'MARA/D.WEST/L.TRUETT WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENDANT CONTINUED ON BOND
07/10/2013 MNFD CIRCUIT COURT RECONVENED WITH DEFENDANT, COUNSEL AND COURT PERSONNEL PRESENT FOR
07/10/2013 MNFD CONTINUED TRIAL.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT SUSTAINED THE STATE'S SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING
07/10/2013 MNFD COMPUTER ANIMATION. COMPUTER ANIMATION MAY ONLY BE USED AS DEMONSTRATIVE AID
07/10/2013 MNFD DURING THE COURSE OF THE TRIAL.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT INQUIRED OF THE DEFENDANT AS TO HIS RIGHT TO TESTIFY ON HIS BEHALF AND THE
07/10/2013 MNFD COURSE OF THE TRIAL. DEFENDANT HAD NO DECISION AT THIS TIME.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT'S ANNOUNCED IT'S PRIOR RULING AS TO THE ADMISSION OF VICTIM'S TEXT
07/10/2013 MNFD MESSAGES STANDS. COURT WILL NOT ALLOW TEXT MESSAGES INTO EVIDENCE.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT FINDS A STATE'S REQUEST FOR DAUBERT HEARING IS.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT RENEWED PRIOR INQUIRY OF DEFENDANT AS TO HIS RIGHT TO TESTIFY AND IF A
07/10/2013 MNFD DECISION HAD BEEN REACHED. DEFENDANT WAS DULY SWORN. DEFENSE ATTORNEY WEST
07/10/2013 MNFD OBJECTED TO THE INQUIRY. DEFENDANT ADVISED THE COURT HE WOULD HAVE A DECISION BY
07/10/2013 MNFD THE END OF THE DAY.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT FURTHER INQUIRY OF DEFENDANT AS TO HSI RIGHT TO TESTIFY AND IF A DECISION
07/10/2013 MNFD HAD BEEN REACHED. DEFENDANT STATED HE WOULD NOT BE TESTIFYING AND THIS WAS HIS
07/10/2013 MNFD SOLE DECISION.
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENSE WITNESSES WERE DULY SWORN AND TESTIFIED.
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENSE EXHIBITS WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED.
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENSE ATTORNEY O'MARA RENEWED ORE TENUS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT OF ACQUITTAL.
07/10/2013 MNFD STATE ATTORNEY MANTEI PRESENTED ARGUMENTS.
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENSE ATTORNEY O'MARA PRESENTED FURTHER ARGUMENTS.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT RENEWED PRIOR FINDING THERE REMAINS SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE BOTH DIRECT AND
07/10/2013 MNFD CIRCUMSTANTIAL, FOR THE CASE TO GO TO THE JURY.
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENSE ATTORNEY O'MARA ANNOUNCED IT RESTS ITS CASE IN CHIEF AT 3:44PM.
07/10/2013 MNFD STATE'S REBUTTAL WITNESS WAS DULY SWORN AND TESTIFIED.
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENSE FILED REQUESTS FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE FOR WEATHER HISTORY FOR DATES 2/26/12
07/10/2013 MNFD AND 2/27/12.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT ORDERS CLERK TO REPLACE STATE'S EXHIBIT "213" KFL SANFO10 WEATHER GRAPHS
07/10/2013 MNFD FOR 2/26/12 WITH COMPOSITE OF 3 PAGES WEATHER HISTORY FOR SANFORD, FL FOR
07/10/2013 MNFD 2/26/12 BY WEATHER UNDERGROUND.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT GAVE CAUTIONARY INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY TO RETURN AT 1:00PM ON THURSDAY,
07/10/2013 MNFD JULY 11, 2013 FOR CONTINUED TRIAL.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT PROCEEDED WITH STATE'S MOTION FOR SANCTIONS AGAINS DEFENSE WITNESS JOHN
07/10/2013 MNFD DONNOLLY FOR VIOLATION OF RULE OF SEQUESTRATION.
07/10/2013 MNFD STATE ATTORNEY MANTEI CITED AND PRESENTED CASE LAW.
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENSE ATTORNEY O'MARA PRESNTED ARGUMENTS.
07/10/2013 MNFD DEFENSE ATTORNEY WEST PRESENTED ADDITIONAL ARGUMENTS.
07/10/2013 MNFD STATE ATTORNEY MANTEI PRESENTED FURTHER ARGUMENTS.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT DOES NOT MAKE A FINDING THAT WITNESS JOHN DONNOLLY WILLFULLY VIOLATED THE
07/10/2013 MNFD RULE OF SEQUESTRATION AT 5:20PM.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT DOES NOT FIND THAT WITNESS JOHN DONNOLLY'S TESTIMONY DID NOT CHANGED OR
07/10/2013 MNFD WAS NOT IMPACTED BY HIS PRESENCE IN THE COURTROOM.
07/10/2013 MNFD COURT DENIED THE STATE'S REQUEST FOR SANCTIONS.
07/10/2013 MNFD PRELIMINARY CHARGE CONFERENCE HELD.
07/10/2013 MNFD STATE TO BEGIN CLOSING ARGUMENTS AT 1:00PM ON THURSDAY, JULY 11, 2013.
07/10/2013 MNFD PARTIES TO APPEAR AT 9:00AM ON THURSDAY, JULY 11, 2013 FOR CHARGE CONFERENCE.
07/10/2013 MNFD DONE AND ORDERED IN OPEN COURT.
07/10/2013 PRES DEFENDANT WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/10/2013 TRJU TRIAL CONTINUED TO 07/11/2013 AT 0900AM IN COURTROOM 5D, AT CRIMINAL JUSTICE
07/10/2013 TRJU --BUILDING BEFORE JUDGE DEBRA S NELSON
07/09/2013 EXID EXHIBIT & IDENTIFICATION LIST
07/09/2013 MOTN STATE'S SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING COMPUTER ANIMATION
07/09/2013 MNF MINUTES FOR TRIAL BEFORE JUDGE DEBRA S NELSON
07/09/2013 MNFD DEFENDANT WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/09/2013 MNFD STATE ATTORNEY BERNIE DE LA RIONDA/JOHN GUY/RICHARD MANTEI WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/09/2013 MNFD DEFENSE ATTORNEY MARK OMARA & DON WEST WAS PRESENT FOR TRIAL
07/09/2013 MNFD TRIAL CONTINUED TO 7/10/13 AT 9:00AM IN COURTROOM 5D, AT THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE
07/09/2013 MNFD BUILDING, 101 BUSH BLVD, SANFORD, FL 32773 BEFORE JUDGE DEBRA S NELSON
07/09/2013 MNFD CIRCUIT COURT RECONVENED WITH DEFENDANT, COUNSEL AND COURT PERSONNEL PRESENT AND
07/09/2013 MNFD READY TO CONTINUE WITH TRIAL.
07/09/2013 MNFD DEFENSE WITNESSES WERE DULY SWORN AND TESTIFIED.
07/09/2013 MNFD DEFENSE EXHIBITS WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED
07/09/2013 MNFD COURT GAVE CAUTIONARY INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY TO RETURN AT 9AM ON JULY 10, 2013
07/09/2013 MNFD TO CONTINUE WITH TRIAL
07/09/2013 MNFD STATE FILED STATE'S SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING COMPUTER
07/09/2013 MNFD ANIMATION WAS FILED IN OPEN COURT.
07/09/2013 MNFD ARGUMENTS WERE PRESENTED BY THE PARTIES AS TO THE STATE'S SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL
07/09/2013 MNFD MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING COMPUTER ANIMATION.
07/09/2013 MNFD ATTORNEY O'MARA CALLED DEFENSE WITNESS NO.1-DANIEL SCHUMAKER WHO WAS DULY
07/09/2013 MNFD SWORN AND TESTIFIED.
07/09/2013 MNFD COURT CONTINUED WITH THE STATE'S SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING
07/09/2013 MNFD THE COMPUTER ANIMATION.
07/09/2013 MNFD ATTORNEY MANTEI BEGAN CROSS EXAMINATION
07/09/2013 MNFD ATTORNEY O'MARA BEGAN REDIRECT EXAMINATION
07/09/2013 MNFD ATTORNEY MANTEI WITH RECROSS EXAMINATION
07/09/2013 MNFD WITNESS STEPPED DOWN.
07/09/2013 MNFD ATTORNEY MANTEI ADVISED THE COURT THAT THE STATE IS NOW SEEKING A DAUBERT
07/09/2013 MNFD HEARING.
07/09/2013 MNFD ATTORNEY O'MARA PRESENTED ARGUMENT TO THE COURT.
07/09/2013 MNFD ATTORENY MANTEI PRESENTED ARGUMENT AND CASE LAW TO THE COURT
07/09/2013 MNFD COURT RESERVED RULING AT THIS TIME.
07/09/2013 MNFD ATTORNEY GUY ADDRESSED THE COURT AS TO THE STATE'S MOTION IN LIMINE.
07/09/2013 MNFD ATTORNEY WEST PRESENTED ARGUMENT DEFENSE MOTION.
07/09/2013 MNFD DEFENSE WITNESS NO.1-RICHARD CONNOR WAS DULY SWORN AND TESTIFIED.
07/09/2013 MNFD EVIDENCE WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED BY THE DEFENSE.
07/09/2013 MNFD ATTORNEY WEST MADE AN ORE TENUS MOTION TO EXTEND DEFENDANT'S CURFEW UNTIL THE
07/09/2013 MNFD CONCLUSION OF THE HEARING.
07/09/2013 MNFD COURT GRANTED THE DEFENSE ORE TENUS MOTION AND EXTENDED DEFENDANT'S CURFEW FOR
07/09/2013 MNFD TONIGHT UNTIL 30 MINUTES PAST THE CONCLUSION OF THIS HEARING.
07/09/2013 MNFD ARGUMENTS WERE PRESENTED AS TOT THE STATE'S MOTION IN LIMINE BY THE PARTIES.
07/09/2013 MNFD COURT RESERVED RULING AT THIS TIME.
07/09/2013 MNFD ALL PENDING MOTION ARE TO BE HEARD AT 8AM ON JULY 10, 2013.
07/09/2013 MNFD DONE AND ORDERED ON THIS 9TH DAY OF JULY 2013 IN OPEN COURT.